Performed by The Toledo Symphony on October 30, 2026 at The Peristyle
Concert Music for Strings and Brass
Paul Hindemith (1895–1963)
Paul Hindemith is one of the foremost German composers of the twentieth century. In addition to composing, he was also a noted conductor, music theorist, educator, and violist.
Hindemith studied violin as a child, then entered the Frankfurt Conservatory as a teenager, where he studied violin and composition. At twenty, Hindemith accepted the position of concertmaster with the Frankfurt Opera Orchestra. This appointment was cut short in 1917, when he was drafted by the German army to fight in a war that had already taken his father’s life. However, he was not deemed physically fit enough to fight, so he spent most of his time in the military band.
As a composer, Hindemith advocated for a return to tonality at a time when many of his colleagues were experimenting with atonality and venturing into the avant-garde. He openly opposed Arnold Schoenberg’s 12-tone school of music and wrote several books on music theory and compositional principles. He also introduced a new style called Gebrauchsmusik, “utility music” – music composed for a purpose beyond pure self-expression. Hindemith famously remarked, “People who make music together cannot be enemies, at least while the music lasts.”
By the late 1920s, Hindemith was one of the most recognized composers of his time and was friendly with many composers and musicians. He worked especially closely with Kurt Weill and Bertolt Brecht. Though he did not openly denounce the rising Nazi party, he had many left-leaning friends and was himself married to a Jewish woman. Hindemith considered himself a modernist and endeavored to maintain his political neutrality at a time when doing so was becoming increasingly dangerous.
In the early 1930s, Hindemith was working on his most well-known work, an opera about the struggles of the painter Matthias Grünewald called Mathis der Maler (“Matthias the Painter”). In 1934, the great conductor Wilhelm Fürtwangler programmed the premiere of an orchestral version of Mathis der Maler for the 1934–35 season of the Berlin Philharmonic, but Hermann Göring banned the new work, calling Hindemith a “cultural Bolshevist” and a “spiritual non-Aryan.” Furtwängler advocated for Hindemith, and the performance was allowed to go ahead, but opening shots had been fired. Only two years earlier, Joseph Goebbels had called Hindemith “unquestionably ... one of the most important talents in the younger generation of composers.” Now, however, Goebbels stated, “[Hindemith is] at home everywhere except in the German folk’s soul.”
Despite the darkening clouds on his horizons, Hindemith continued to work and contribute to a variety of musical genres, including chamber music, experimental works for the theater, lieder, and children’s music. But slowly he began to find it more difficult to program his music as the Nazi party secured their control over Germany’s cultural institutions. Seeing what was coming, he asked to be released from his teaching post in Berlin to accept a new teaching post at Turkey’s Ankara Conservatory. In 1936, Hindemith was required to sign a pledge of loyalty to Hitler if he wanted to return home. He chose to move he and his wife to Switzerland instead. The couple emigrated to the US shortly after this, and Hindemith began teaching at Yale, where he stayed until 1953, when he was able to finally move back to Germany.
Hindemith’s Konzertmusik for Strings and Brass, Op. 50 was composed in 1930, before the controversy surrounding Mathis der Maler (this whole episode is sometimes known as “the Hindemith affair”). The op. 50 Konzertmusik is the third piece in a set of three konzertmusiks that Hindemith completed in 1930. His op. 48 is for solo viola and chamber orchestra, and op. 49 for piano, brass, and two harps. Konzertmusik, op. 50 is in two main parts, with clear sections in each. The first part is marked at a moderate tempo, powerful and broad yet fluid. The second part is lively, then slow.
Hindemith’s Konzertmusik was commissioned by Serge Koussevitzky for the fiftieth anniversary of the Boston Symphony Orchestra and was premiered by that ensemble in March 1931. It is scored for four trumpets, four horns, three trombones, tuba, and strings.
Piano Concerto No. 3 in D Minor, Op. 30
Sergei Rachmaninoff (1873–1943)
In 1906, Sergei Rachmaninoff moved to Germany from Russia with his family. His career had been successful, if a little rocky, up until then, and he was a respected conductor and the best pianist of his time. He was also a prolific composer, and had produced two piano concertos, various chamber and solo piano works, a slew of songs, and three operas. Additionally, he’d completed the first of his three symphonies, the rejection of which caused him such anxiety and anguish. Annotator Michael Steinberg explains the reason for the Rachmaninoffs’ move as “an attempt to take himself out of circulation [as a performer, so that he might have more time for composing], and he chose the beautiful Saxon capital [Dresden] because he and his wife had become fond of it on their honeymoon four years earlier.”
Rachmaninoff wrote his Piano Concerto No. 3 in 1909 while preparing to embark on a concert tour of the United States, where he planned to premiere the work. Steinberg notes that he must surely have been anxious about writing this piece, since overcoming the aftermath of his first symphony and composing the second concerto and second symphony had been such a battle for him. To make things even more daunting, those works had been awarded many accolades, and the pressure was on for him to live up to expectations. Rachmaninoff’s tour began in November of 1909, and he premiered his new piano concerto on the 28th of that month with Walter Damrosch and the New York Symphony Society.
Rachmaninoff made wonderful and notable starts to each of his piano concertos. The third is different in its simplicity. Rachmaninoff achieves a wonderful balance in this concerto, and in this movement in particular, between the solo part and the full orchestra. Annotator Steven Ledbetter notes, “The theme and its rustling accompaniment both play a role in the progress of the movement…. This begins a dialogue between the soloist and orchestra…” Rachmaninoff reportedly told musicologist Joseph Yasser that the theme had come to him “already made” and essentially “wrote itself.” This was not the case with the accompanimental material. Rachmaninoff said that he was looking for a specific sound, and was thinking of the solo part “as a singer would sing it, and [finding] a suitable orchestral accompaniment, or rather, one that would not muffle this singing.”
The second movement, the Intermezzo, is marked adagio, and incredibly expressive. It opens with the orchestra alone playing a phrase that is interrupted by the entrance of the solo part. Rachmaninoff spins out the themes in a series of variations around what Steinberg calls “a featherlight waltz that perhaps represents Rachmaninoff’s memory of a similar interruption in the slow movement of Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concerto No. 1.” Listen for the melody in the bassoon and clarinet in this movement. Rachmaninoff also uses this movement to move between various harmonies, finally coming back to the opening, which the soloist interrupts with a short cadenza that prepares us tonally for the Finale.
The Finale is brilliant, virtuosic, and spirited. Ledbetter describes it as “sunny by turns… [with] increasingly ornate miniature variations,” and Steinberg as a “torrent of… invention.” In this movement, Rachmaninoff ties the whole work together by referencing the first two movements.
Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No. 3 is a tall order for any soloist, being wickedly technically difficult, as well as lengthy and unrelenting for the soloist. Steinberg notes, “few pianists would agree with Rachmainoff’s own estimate that the Third Concerto is ‘more comfortable’ than the Second. Moreover… Rachmaninoff sees the soloist not merely as someone who can sing soulfully and thunder imposingly, but as an alert, flexible, responsive musician who knows how to blend, accompany, and listen.”
Following the premiere, Rachmaninoff performed the concerto again with Walter Damrosch a few days later at Carnegie Hall. Though it was received warmly, it was not quite as instantly popular as the second concerto. Critics seem to have agreed that the concerto was just too long and had too much going on. The New York Herald pointed out, “its length and difficulties bar it from performances by any but pianists of exceptional technical powers.” Nevertheless, it was well within Rachmaninoff’s own powers. He continued his tour, both performing and conducting, and was offered the opportunity to conduct the Boston Symphony on a permanent basis. He declined, explaining, “I am weary of America and I have had more than enough… Just imagine: to concertize almost every day during the three months! I have played my own compositions exclusively. I was a great success and I was recalled to give encores as many as seven times. This was a great deal, considering the audiences there. The audiences are remarkably cold, spoiled by the guest performances of first-class artists, those audiences which always seek something extraordinary, something different from the last one. Their newspapers always remark on how many times the artist was recalled to take a bow and for the large public this is the yardstick of your talent, if you please.” Indeed, the New York Herald did include that very information in the review of the premiere: “Mr. Rachmaninoff was recalled several times in the determined effort of the audience to make him play again, but he held up his hands with a gesture which meant that although he was willing, his fingers were not. So the audience laughed and let him retire.”
Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No. 3 is scored for two flutes, two oboes, two clarinets, two bassoons, four horns, two trumpets, three trombones, tuba, timpani, percussion, and strings.
Symphony No. 9, Op. 95 "From the New World"
Antonín Dvořák (1841-1904)
The second half of the nineteenth century was not a particularly good period in the German symphonic tradition. The number of symphonies being written was dwindling, as composers concentrated on other forms. Richard Wagner famously claimed that the symphony was dead as Europe tried to recover from the half century of political unrest in the wake of the Napoleonic wars. Also, the system of aristocratic patronage was beginning to fall apart and public demand for music hadn’t caught up enough to warrant the construction of concert halls large enough to accommodate the symphony orchestra as it was expanded.
The flip side of the post-war confusion was the surge in nationalistic sentiment, which resulted in a number of commissions, and this effort to reclaim and/or redefine elements special to national cultures impacted the work of a number of composers, including Antonín Dvořák. Although, as musicologist David Hurwitz notes, Dvořák was especially successful at reconciling the genre’s “classical roots with the Romantic love of virtuoso display, heightened emotion expression, integration of ethnic or national musical elements, and colorful exploitation of the full resources of the modern orchestra,” he was not a musical revolutionary. On the contrary, Dvořák loved the symphonic tradition, and his music skirts the divide between “respectful homage and originality of form and content.” In Europe, Dvořák was known especially for his compositions that made use of Slavic folk music, a usage that would serve him well abroad as well.
In 1893, Dvořák accepted a posting as Director of the National Conservatory in New York City. Part of his charge during his tenure was to write a new work reflecting his impressions of America. Musicologist Maurice Peress suggests that this assignment was prompted partly by the previous year’s four hundredth anniversary of Columbus’s landing on American soil, something that had caused a sort of stock-taking. What had been achieved during the previous four hundred years and what did the future hold? In a speech titled “Two New Worlds: the New World of Columbus and the New World of Music,” Americanist Thomas Wentworth Higginson said, “The triumphs of our land in music … lie in the future…. If we were all made of unmixed English blood, we might have long to wait for them…. We are not all of English blood. We stand in one of the great German cities of the world, and the other great musical race of Europe is making our very byways Italian…. Let us hope that our guest tonight [Dvořák] ... may consent to transplantation and may help add the new world of music to the continent which Columbus found.” The work that Dvořák produced was “From the New World,” or simply, “New World.”
As we can see from his extensive use of folk music in his earlier works, Dvořák held a deep-seated conviction that folk music was key to developing an authentic national voice or style in music. For America, he believed that this folk music was best represented by Negro and Native American Indian themes. Needless to say, this opinion was highly debated, but Dvořák had plenty of support to work as he wished. More than a quarter of his students at the conservatory were African American, some of whom were directly familiar with their musics. Many of his students went on to teach musicians such as George Gershwin, Aaron Copland, Duke Ellington, and others, rendering Dvořák’s impact on American music of all kinds almost incalculable.
One of Dvořák’s students in particular played a very important role in the conception of the “New World” Symphony and is credited with introducing Dvořák to the songs that he finally used in the work. Harry Burleigh learned many plantation songs and spirituals from his maternal grandfather, Hamilton Waters, who had been a slave but bought his freedom in 1832. The family was Episcopalian, and Burleigh grew up singing in the choir. In his own program note on the “New World” Symphony, Burleigh wrote: “There is a tendency in these days to ignore the negro elements in the “New World” Symphony, shown by the fact that many of those who were able in 1893 to find traces of negro musical color all through the Symphony, though the workmanship and treatment of the themes was and is Bohemian, now cannot find anything in the whole four movements that suggests any local or negro influence, though there is no doubt at all that Dr. Dvořák was deeply impressed by the old Negro Spirituals and also by the Foster songs.
“It was my privilege to repeatedly sing some of the old Plantation songs for him at his home in E. 17th St. and one in particular, “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot” greatly pleased him, and part of this old Spiritual will be found in the second theme of the first movement of the Symphony…. The similarity is so evident that it doesn’t even need to be heard; the eye can see it. Dvořák just saturated himself with the spirit of these old tunes and then invented his own themes.
“There is a subsidiary theme in the first movement … and I feel sure the Doctor caught this peculiarity of most of the slave songs from some that I sang to him; for he used to stop me and ask if that was the way the slaves sang.
“I have never publicly been credited with exerting any influence upon Dr. Dvořák, although it is tacitly believed that there isn’t much doubt about it, for I was with him almost constantly, and he loved to hear me sing the old melodies. Walter Damrosch once alluded to my having brought these songs to Dvorak’s attention, but there was so much discussion and difference of opinion as to the value of the intimation that in the songs of the negroes lay the basis for a national school of music and the controversy waxed so hot that all reference to the real source of his information was lost sight of.”
Music critic James Huneker reportedly remarked, half joking, that maybe Dvořák only came to the United States to “rifle us of our native ore.” However, he didn’t actually copy the melodies but used them as aesthetic inspiration (with the possible exception of “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot,” as mentioned by Burleigh).
In the first movement, Dvořák makes a point of integrating his melodic material strictly into the traditional forms. Peress uses the term “old-fashioned,” and explains that “however unusual, [it] has as much right to be used as part of a large classical design as any theme by Beethoven.” The exposition presents the main thematic material, and Dvořák cleverly incorporates a bit of call and response into the first subject. The second subject in the flute is a mirror theme and the first reference to “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot.” Dvořák calls for the exposition to be repeated, something he hadn’t done in previous symphonies.
The second movement, which Peress calls “the famous largo,” features a really lovely chorale in the brass and one of the most well-known solos for English horn in the repertoire. “Attempting to describe it is like trying to analyze the taste of a ripe peach … [it represents a] primal realm of musical being … [with] pristine simplicity of utterance.” Burleigh tells us that Dvořák used “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot” verbatim here: “It was not an accident. He did it quite consciously…. He tried to combine Negro and Indian themes.”
Burleigh also sheds light on another important reference to Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s “Hiawatha”: Pleasant was the journey homeward!/ All the birds sang loud and sweetly/ Songs of happiness and heart’s-ease;/ Sang the bluebird, to Owaissa,/ “Happy are you, Hiawatha,/ Having such a wife to love you!”/ Sang the robin, the Opeechee,/ “Happy are you, Laughing Water,/ Having such a noble husband!” Burleigh claimed that Hiawatha “had a great effect on him and he wanted to interpret it musically.” Peress points out that the fact that Burleigh’s grandmother was part Native American might also have contributed to Dvořák’s blithe equation of Indian and African American musics.
The third movement begins similarly to some of Dvořák’s “Slavonic Dances,” and the scherzo character brightens things in the wake of the Largo. The main folk reference in this movement appears in the Trio section, which features a tune similar to “Over the River and Through the Woods, to Grandmother’s House We Go.”
The finale opens with a marchlike melody underscored by what Peress calls Dvořák’s “most graphic train tunes … [in reference to the] huffing and puffing continuation in triplets on the strings and horns.” The image is topped off with the “hiss of escaping steam” at the end of the section, rendered by the suspended cymbal. The secondary melody is presented by the clarinets and is a lovely foil to the mechanical element of the trains. In the development section, Dvořák revisits all the principal themes from the previous movements before heading into the recapitulation, where the brass chorale with timpani reinforces the climax. Peress describes the transition to the coda as “mournful,” and the “ensuing grinding dissonances in the brass, produced by the collision of the main theme of the finale with the first movement’s motto, offer the greatest surprise of all: this is actually a tragic finale, like the Seventh [Symphony’s].”
Dvořák used a technique called cyclical construction throughout the movements, including hints of movements in other movements to promote cohesion across the work. He also used elements of variation form to unify the structure. Peress points out that this symphony has something of the same bewitching element common to much of Mozart’s work, where “the music’s sheer beauty and lovability makes it easy to forget just how emotionally expressive it really is.”
Huneker praised Dvořák for his “fresh, vigorous talent … [he] was a born Impressionist, and possessed a happy colour sense in his orchestration.” Unfortunately, Dvořák didn’t write any more symphonies after this one, which became his farewell to the genre.
The “New World” Symphony is scored for two flutes and piccolo, two oboes and English horn, two clarinets, two bassoons, two trumpets, two trombones and bass trombone, tuba, four horns, percussion, and strings.



Leave a Comment
Comments
0 comments on "Rachmaninoff & New World Symphony Program Notes"